256 pages
Mr. Griffin is tough on his high school English students. He won't accept late assignments and he never gives As, so group of students decide to get revenge. They're a motley crew: Mark, who originally has the idea, is cold and cunning; David is sweet but insecure; Jeff is outgoing; Betsy will do anything to be popular. Susan is the real misfit, as she is quiet, mousy, and shy and doesn't hang out with the rest of the kids, who are the "in crowd." But she's got a big crush on David, so it's not too hard for him to talk her into helping them with their plot to get back at Mr. Griffin. All they're going to do is kidnap him, take him out in the woods, make them think that they're going to kill him, and make him beg for his life. They aren't really going to hurt him. But of course things go terribly wrong, and the kids end up with a dead body on their hands. No one can agree about what do to--and it soon becomes clear that one member of the group will stop at nothing to keep from getting caught.
I enjoyed the idea of this book and the message behind it, but I didn't really have that much fun reading it. The plot is pretty predictable and the characters fall flat to me, for the most part (with the exception of David's Gram). Also, the specific book that I read was an updated version, which confused me at first because I knew that the book was published in the late 1970s but they were talking about iPods, Google, and DVDs. Even after I realized that the book had been updated, it still seemed odd because other details were old-fashioned (the kids' names, the dialogue, etc). I don't see why they felt the need to update a book like that. It's like they think that kids these days can't concentrate on a book that doesn't have tons of computers, phones, and fancy stuff. That's probably true in some cases, but that doesn't mean we should go around changing all the older books. Okay, I'll get off my soapbox...as I said, this book isn't my favorite but it has some redeeming qualities.
Having long ago exhausted my local library's collection of Lois Duncans, I was searching AbeBooks for some comfort reading during lockdown(I'm locked down without most of my own book collection and the libraries are, surprise surpise, shut) and found Killing Mr Griffin. Yes, there's a lot of predictability, but what really surprised me, after having read Stranger with my face countless times and still finding it totally compulsive while neither understanding nor agreeing with Duncan's implied premiss that some people are just born evil, was that in Killing Mr G she (admittedly through a character, but it comes across to me that she agrees) describes Mark as a psychopath.
ReplyDeleteI find the idea of updating to give characters mobile phones etc. farcical.. Let's have mobiles in Hamlet next. I'm so glad I got (without realising there was an alternative) the original edition.
My absolute favourite line is the end of Ch 4 (orig edn):
"Never, Susan thought deliriously, never in all the time to come will I ever, ever be as happy as I am right now.
And she was right."
There must be some way of applying that to the cliché about one's wedding being the happiest day of one's life.